Farrs Lane Development Ltd v Bristol Magistrates' Court (2016) - fees and enforcement
Farrs Lane Development Ltd v Bristol Magistrates' Court confirms important points about surveyors' fees, awards and statutory enforcement.
Overview
R (Farrs Lane Development Ltd) v Bristol Magistrates' Court concerned the enforcement of party wall awards containing surveyors' fees. It is useful because it shows that fee provisions in a valid award can have direct enforcement consequences.
What happened
A developer challenged magistrates' court orders enforcing sums awarded for surveyors' fees. The challenge was brought by judicial review after the magistrates declined to state a case.
The decision
The High Court held that section 10 is wide enough for surveyors to award reasonable costs payable to themselves and that sums properly awarded can be enforced through the statutory recovery mechanism.
Why it matters
An owner should not simply ignore a fee provision because they disagree with it. The proper questions are whether the award is valid, whether the surveyors had jurisdiction, whether the costs were reasonably incurred and whether any appeal or challenge is brought by the correct route and in time.
Practical lesson
Award wording should state clearly who must pay, what is payable and why. Surveyors should also be able to justify the reasonableness of the costs awarded.