Frances Holland School v Wassef (2001) - ownership, estoppel and ex parte procedure
A predecessor-legislation case on who qualified as an owner, estoppel and the need for strict compliance when a surveyor acts ex parte.
Overview
Frances Holland School v Wassef [2001] 2 EGLR 88 was decided under the London Building Acts (Amendment) Act 1939, the predecessor to the Party Wall etc. Act 1996. It remains useful by analogy, but it should not be presented as a direct decision under section 10 of the 1996 Act.
Ownership point
The Wassefs were statutory tenants under the Rent Act 1977. The court held that they were not “owners” for the purposes of the relevant predecessor legislation because they did not hold the qualifying legal interest.
Ex parte award
The adjoining owner's surveyor purported to act ex parte on the basis that the building owner's surveyor had refused or neglected to act. The court found no sufficient evidence of refusal or neglect and held that the statutory ex parte procedure had not been followed correctly. The ex parte award was invalid.
The case is a strong reminder that a surveyor who relies on an ex parte power must identify the correct statutory basis and comply strictly with the conditions for using it.
Estoppel
The case also considered the effect of the parties having proceeded for a period on shared assumptions about the statutory process. That issue is fact-sensitive and should not be treated as a general power to cure defective jurisdiction. In particular, it did not save the defective ex parte award.
Why it matters
Check ownership and appointment issues early. If ex parte action is contemplated, record precisely whether the alleged basis is refusal or a failure to act effectively following the relevant request, and make sure the award matches the statutory route actually relied upon.