← Back to the library
Party Wall case lawParty Wall authority

Patel v Peters (2014) - ex parte awards and the ten-day shortcut

Patel v Peters is important for surveyors who use, or face, ex parte awards.

By Karmjit Grewal · 2 min read · Reviewed 2026-09-26

Overview

Patel v Peters is important for surveyors who use, or face, ex parte awards.

It shows that the ten-day mechanism is not a trap to be sprung after the other surveyor has actually responded.

What happened

There was a fee dispute. The adjoining owner's surveyor made an ex parte award for fees after the building owner's surveyor failed to respond within the ten-day period.

The building owner's surveyor did respond before the award was actually made, but the response was late.

The decision

The court held that once the other surveyor responded before the award was made, the power to proceed ex parte came to an end.

Why it matters

Ex parte powers exist to stop the process being blocked by a genuine refusal or neglect to act effectively.

They should not be used as a tactical ambush where the other surveyor has re-engaged before the award is made.

Practical lesson

If you are considering an ex parte award, check the correspondence timeline carefully.

If the issue is mainly fees, consider whether referral to the third surveyor is the better and safer route.