← Back to the library
Party Wall case lawCourt of Appeal – binding authority

Reeves v Blake (2009) - why party wall surveyors cannot award litigation costs

Reeves v Blake draws an important line between statutory party wall costs and the costs of preparing for court proceedings.

By Karmjit Grewal · 2 min read · Reviewed 2026-09-26

Overview

Reeves v Blake [2009] EWCA Civ 611 draws an important line between the statutory party wall process and litigation in court. Surveyors may determine reasonable costs arising out of a dispute under the Act, but they cannot award the costs of preparing for an injunction or other court proceedings.

What happened

The building owner served notices under sections 1 and 6. A third surveyor later held that the section 1 notice was invalid but the section 6 notice was valid. The building owner began foundation work believing the award permitted it to proceed. The adjoining owner disagreed and instructed solicitors and counsel to prepare an injunction claim. An undertaking was then given and no court proceedings were issued.

The issue

The adjoining owner sought to recover the legal costs of preparing the threatened injunction through the party wall process.

The decision

The Court of Appeal held that surveyors' cost jurisdiction is confined to costs connected with the statutory dispute-resolution mechanism. Costs of actual or contemplated proceedings for common-law or equitable remedies such as injunctions, trespass or nuisance fall outside that mechanism.

Why it matters

The case does not say surveyors can never deal with legal costs. It says the costs must arise from the statutory dispute itself. Litigation costs are for the court to deal with, not for a party wall award.

See also What is a party wall award?