← Back to the library
Awards & process

Can a party wall award be made after excavation has already taken place?

A party wall award cannot retrospectively make an invalid statutory process valid or treat work as authorised before it was carried out. The first question…

By Karmjit Grewal · 2 min read · Reviewed 2026-09-26

The short answer

A party wall award cannot retrospectively make an invalid statutory process valid or treat work as authorised before it was carried out. The first question is whether the Act was validly engaged in the first place.

If no building-owner notice was served

Power v Shah is the important modern authority. Where the statutory process has not been triggered by the required building-owner notice, an adjoining owner cannot simply invoke section 10 after the works and obtain a valid retrospective award. “No notice” is not something an award can cure after the event.

If a valid notice and dispute already existed

The position is different where a valid notice was served, a statutory dispute arose and surveyors were properly appointed, but the physical works overtook the award process. The surveyors must still identify a matter that they have jurisdiction to determine. Depending on the facts, that may include a genuine later dispute over damage, compensation, expenses or another matter arising under the Act.

The award should not pretend that completed work was authorised beforehand. It should accurately record what has happened and determine only matters that remain within jurisdiction.

What to do now

  • Establish whether a valid notice was served before relying on the statutory dispute-resolution machinery.
  • Record exactly what work has already been carried out and inspect for alleged damage where appropriate.
  • Identify the present dispute before asking surveyors to make a further award.
  • Do not use a generic “reservation of jurisdiction” to manufacture a later dispute.

Common mistakes

  • Calling an award “retrospective” as though that cures the absence of a notice.
  • Backdating or drafting an award as if completed work had been authorised in advance.
  • Assuming an old appointment gives the surveyors an unlimited continuing mandate.

When to call Coburns

If excavation has already taken place, send us the notices, appointments, drawings and chronology. The answer depends first on whether the Act was validly engaged and what dispute, if any, now remains.