Seeff v Ho (2011) - informal consent and party wall procedure
Seeff v Ho shows why an informal neighbour agreement is normally understood on the basis that lawful planning and party wall procedures will still be followed.
Overview
Seeff v Ho [2011] EWCA Civ 186 concerned informal consent to building work, later deviations from the approved scheme and trespass. It is a useful warning against treating a friendly conversation as permission to ignore formal legal requirements.
What happened
The neighbours discussed the proposed garage conversion over the garden fence. The trial judge found that oral consent had been given to raising the roof. The works later differed from the planning permission, and the owners had not followed the party wall procedure.
The Court of Appeal's approach
The Court of Appeal held that the informal consent had to be understood objectively. A neighbour giving consent would ordinarily expect the work to be carried out lawfully: planning requirements would be followed and, where the Party Wall Act applied, its procedures would be observed. Compliance with those lawful processes was therefore implicit in the consent.
Because the works departed from the planning permission, they fell outside the basis on which the consent had been given and amounted to trespass. The Court of Appeal did not need finally to decide whether a Party Wall notice was required on the particular facts, although it emphasised that the Act makes notice mandatory for work falling within it.
Why it matters
Planning permission is not party wall consent, and informal neighbour consent should not be treated as a waiver of whatever statutory procedures apply. If consent is important, record it precisely and make sure the work carried out matches the scheme that was discussed.
Practical lesson
If the Act applies, serve the appropriate notice. If a neighbour has informally agreed to something, confirm exactly what has been agreed in writing and do not assume the agreement authorises materially different work.